| Lesson
12: Crisis Theory and Intervention
Objectives
Introduction/Overview
What
is a Crisis?
Kinds
of Crises
Who
Deals with Crisis
Crisis
Theory
Crisis
Intervention
Practice
Quiz 12
Internet
Activities
Answer
to Practice Quiz 12
[TOP]
Objectives
- To
introduce students to crisis theory and different forms
of crisis intervention, and prevention.
- To
help students understand the application of the human
relations counseling model to crisis interventions
prevention.
[TOP]
Introduction/Overview
Helpers are increasingly engaged in crisis intervention and
disaster relief. Lesson
12 presents an overview of basic crisis theory.
It discusses the application of helping relationship
skills and appropriate strategies of the human relations
counseling model to this particular type of helping.
Crisis intervention is differentiated from trauma and
disaster intervention in that the latter is more likely to
require coordinated team efforts to deliver services to
larger groups of sufferers.
Lesson 12 begins by defining crisis and the six
generally accepted classes of emotional crises:
dispositional; anticipated life transitions;
traumatic stress; maturation/developmental;
psychopathological; and psychiatric emergencies.
Crisis intervention and disaster relief are
short-term and focused. Attention
is directed toward reduction of tension and adaptive problem
solving. The
chapter relates the stages and steps of the human relations
counseling model to the stages and steps of crisis
intervention. With
its active focus on finding solutions, brief therapy is
described as a viable form of crisis intervention.
Different formats of crisis intervention, such as hot
lines, drop-in centers, crisis centers, outreach counseling,
disaster relief, and crisis prevention, are described.
Available support networks are considered critical
components of crisis intervention.
This review of crisis theory/intervention indicates
that short-term interventions can be effective.
[TOP]
What is a Crisis?
It is a state that exists when a person is thrown
completely off balance emotionally by an unexpected and
potentially harmful event or a difficult developmental
transition. Unlike
stress that can be ongoing, a crisis is limited.
Results of a crisis can be described as
disequilibrium, disorientation, and disruption, and common
feeling responses are apathy, depression, guilt, and loss of
self-esteem; the usual problem solving techniques no longer
work, causing upset and fright.
People react differently to similar situations; for
one a situation is a crisis, for another it is not.
So a crisis worker deals with a person’s perception
of the situation, not the situation itself.
[TOP]
Kinds of Crises
Crises are either situational (result of internal
stresses, external stresses, or both) or developmental
(passing through stages of life).
Six classes of emotional crises:
- Dispositional
crises: Lack of information such as not knowing which
job to take, what type of medical referral to seek for a
particular symptom, etc.
- Anticipated
life transitions: developmental crises that are fairly
common in our society such as midlife career changes,
getting married, divorce, onset of terminal illness.
- Traumatic
stress: externally
imposed stress situations – rape, assault, sudden
death of loved one, loss of job or status, etc.
- Maturational
developmental crises: Life stages that reflect issues of
dependency, value conflicts sexual identity, capacity
for emotional intimacy, response to authority, or our
level of self-discipline.
- Psychopathological
crises: Precipitated by preexisting psychopathology,
which impairs or complicates the way one deals with a
situation.
- Psychiatric
emergencies: severely impaired where one becomes
incompetent or dangerous to oneself, to others, or to
both.
Cries fall into two main categories (helps determine
crisis intervention means): developmental – have to do
with growth and passing through life stages; or situational
– result of internal stresses, external stresses, or both.
Complete Exercise 9.2 on crises classification
[TOP]
Who
Deals with Crises?
Depending on level of crisis, different interveners.
There is need for professional psychiatric help for
psychiatric emergencies, and professional psychological help
for psychopathology. Anyone can help with dispositional
crises, and many can help with life transitions, traumatic
stress, and developmental crises.
Police, friends, family, pastors, physicians are
usually alerted in crises.
They usually call counselors/human service workers
who help with problem solving, and work through feelings
associated with crisis.
[TOP]
Crisis
Theory
Pioneered by Eric Lindermann who studied reactions of
bereaved families of victims who died in the Coconut Grove
nightclub fire in
Boston
(1944). Discovered
that crisis involves loss (with feelings such as tightness
in the throat, shortened breath, exhaustion, lack of
strength, digestive problems, insomnia, guilt, disturbed
relationships) and requires a period of grieving (about six
weeks).
Caplan and Lindermann believed that in crisis, people
choose adaptive or maladaptive ways; their problem solving
ways will affect their later adjustment and coping.
They believed that people can be taught to identify,
understand and master the psychological tasks of grieving.
Caplan identifies four phases of crisis reaction:
- Person
uses usual kinds of problem solving to restore
equilibrium
- Increase
in tension as usual problem solving strategies fail
- Increased
tension requiring additional helping strategies and
novel problem-solving strategies
- Problem
not resolved in previous phases may result in major
personality disorganization and emotional breakdown.
Lindemann and Caplan indicate that a person in crisis
can be receptive to major change in a brief period of time
and can be influenced and helped by others; also, needs a
much support as possible form whoever is available –
helper, family, friends, etc.
Adaptive crisis resolution can result in enduring,
positive change.
Unresolved bereavement from earlier losses (person,
relationship, security, capacity, a dream) that may be
traumatic (physical, sexual, or emotional abuse) or not,
affects later day-to-day functioning; it also affects
one’s reactions to later crises.
Thus, for best choice of intervention strategies, it
is important to have a good history of crisis victim.
Crisis theory is heavily influenced by major theories
discussed in earlier lessons: suicide research, which
focuses on relation of current crisis to previous
experiences such as birth trauma, birth order, damilial and
interpersonal relationships, shows psychodynamic influence;
focus on here and now, positive growth potential, shows
phenomenological and existential influence; supportive
relationships with significant other, empathic helper,
allowance of expression of intense feelings show influence
of phenomenological influence; cognitive appraisal, and
correction of faulty thinking in crisis intervention
indicates cognitive theory; reinforcement and problem
solving shows cognitive-behavio0ral influence; focus on
significant relationships shows ecological/systems
influence; and focus on race, culture, class and sexual
orientation shows multicultural theoretical orientation.
Major difference between helping strategies and crisis
intervention strategies: crisis intervention strategies
focus on on immediate, time-linited reactions to a specific
source of stress.
[TOP]
Crisis Intervention:
Goal: provide as much support and assistance as possible to
individuals and their families thus enabling the regaining
of psychological equilibrium ASAP.
Six major components of crisis intervention:
- Focus
is on specific and time-limited treatment goals
(attention on tension reduction and problem solving).
- Clarification
and accurate assessment of the stress source and the
meaning of the stress to helpee – entails active,
directive cognitive restructuring.
- Assist
helpee develop adaptive problem-solving mechanism os as
to teturn to former level of functioning
- Reality-oriented,
and focus on clarifying cognitive perceptions,
confronting denial and distortions, and providing
emotional support (not false assurance).
- For
support uses existing helpee relationships as much as
possible
- May
serve as a prelude to further treatment.
BASIC ID model of Lazarus is a good comprehensive
assessment for crisis intervention – elicit information on
the seven levels from which appropriate strategies can be
developed.
Complete Exercise 9.4
Stages and Steps of Crisis Intervention
Stage 1 – Relationship
Step 1: Initiation/entry
- Assess
cognitive, affective, and behavioral reactions to crisis
and impact of same
- Explore
significant relationship systems
- Create
ongoing opportunities for helpee to express and
ventilate intense feelings
Step 2: Clarification of problem/crisis
- Assess
major environmental variables (social physical,
economic, emotional
- Determine
helpee’s perceptions of strengths/weaknesses
- Determine
precipitating events of crisis
- Determine
reason helpee is seeking help
- Determine
kinds of problem solving and coping strategies helpee
has attempted
- Assess
phase and classification of crisis (dangerous to self or
others, etc).
Step 3: Structure/contract
·
Inform helpee what help you
can give/not give to help overcome the crisis
Step 4: Intensive
exploration of crisis and reactions
Step 5: Goals and Objectives, time limits
·
Reiterate problem focus
·
Reaffirm time limits
·
Determine how other people and
resources to be used
·
Clarify who is responsible for
each part
Stage 2: Strategies
Step 1: Mutual acceptance of defined goals and
objectives
Step2: Use of
strategies
- Cognitive
restructuring
- Referral
- Supportive,
empathic, responsive listening
- Assertiveness
training
- Behavioral
contract
- Ventilation
of feelings
- Decision
making
- Systematic
desensitization
- Gestalt
experiments
Step 4: Evaluation
of strategies
Step 5: Termination
when crisis is resolved
- Formulate
realistic plan
- Verify
that helpee is detached from intense emotional reaction
- Confirm
accurate cognitive appraisal of crisis and appropriate
management of affect by helpee
- Helpee
willing to accept help from others as appropriate
- Helpee
understands how present crisis can help in coping with
future events
Step 6: Determine
whether crisis resolution endured
Brief
Therapy
Solution-focused therapy limited to ten or fewer
sessions. Four step helping model of Watzlawick, Weakland,
and Fisch (1974) appropriate to crisis intervention:
- Describe
crisis in concrete behavioral terms
- Investigate
previous attempts at problem resolution
- Obtain
a clear definition of the change to be achieved
- Formulate
and implement a plan to produce the change.
Forms of Crisis
Intervention
Three main forms:
- Hotlines,
drop-in centers, and crisis clinics (deal with suicide,
drug, runaway, rape, alcoholic, abortion crises, etc.,
by helpers with special training)
- Outreach
counseling (based on visiting nursing concept, helpers
go and provide immediate support and comfort to crisis
victims –see victim in context/own environment and
hence more expensive)
- Disaster
relief (teams work with victims of major catastrophes
Crisis
Prevention
Many educational programs in colleges and communities
to hep people avoid certain kinds of crises –
developmental crises, rape-prevention, sex-education,
drug-education, etc.
Skills
for Crisis Intervention
The ability to: remain calm in an emergency; use
common sense; project self-confidence; responsive listening
communication skills; communicate comfort, support, and
respect to helpee; differentiate empathy (important for
faster recovery in most crises) from sympathy (use in
bereavement only), and confrontation (confront remorseful
alcoholic with the consequences of physical abuse toward his
wife); be able to work quickly; and know community resources
thoroughly.
In the beginning steps of crisis intervention, the
helper poses questions about event in order to elicit
information and determine best intervention strategies.
At the same time, communicate comfort, support and
respect for victim and take direct action where necessary
(prevent danger to self or others).
Dependency on helper is accepted until ready for
referral or victim can take over for self.
Reactions to crises involving loss (divorce, death)
have stages as outlined by Kubler-Ross (1969):
initial shock and denial (can’t happen to me –
helper provides empathetic support), anger (helper can get
the brunt of it), acceptance (coping strengths emerge).
Complete
Exercise 9.9
[TOP]
Practice Quiz 12
- A
crisis is when a person is thrown completely off balance
emotionally by an unexpected and potentially harmful
event or a difficult developmental transition.
T/F
- Sudden
loss of a job or status is an example of a dispositional
crisis. T/F
- Crises
result in disequilibrium, disorientation, and
disruption. T/F
- Lindemann
and Caplan were opposed to community mental health
clinics as sources of crisis intervention.
T/F
- As
described by Caplan, phase four of a crisis reaction may
result in major personality disorganization and an
emotional breakdown.
T/F
- Cognitive
theory is not helpful for crisis intervention work.
T/F
- Crisis
intervention is strictly short term and should never
lead to further treatment.
T/F
- Outreach
counseling is usually inexpensive.
T/F
- College
and community educational programs can be helpful in the
prevention of certain kinds of crises.
T/F
- The
ability to remain calm in an emergency is an important
skill of the crisis intervention helper.
T/F
[TOP]
Internet Activities
- Review
newspaper and news magazine articles (that can be
accessed from the Internet) about a recent local or
international crisis or disaster.
- Ask
students to find web sites that are helpful in
understanding crisis prevention and intervention, as
well as disaster relief programs.
Consider:
International
Federation of Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies: www.ifrc.org
American
Foundation for Suicide Prevention
www.afsp.org/index-1.htm
American
Association of Suicidality
www.suicidology.org
United
Nations High commissioner for Refugees
www.unhcr.ch/
|
|